Fuel Cell Construction and Performance Characterisation

This page describes how the internal construction and fluid flows within a fuel cell effects it's performance, the voltage-current output characteristic and the efficiency. Implications for the fuel flow control and voltage regulation are considered, and the method for characterising the performance in our assessment model briefly described.

Gibbs energy and open circuit voltage

We have seen that the theoretical electric potential derives from the Gibbs energy, and that when no current is drawn the electrochemical reaction is reversible. Hence:

W = Wmax = dG = 0 and Voc = Emf = -dG/nF

The theoretical open circuit voltage is equal to the theoretical potential at the operating temperature and pressure, and the voltage efficiency is 100%.

Concepts and systems

Sustainable energy

CHP systems

Biofuels

Potential

Applications

Fuel Cells

Gibbs energy

Reformers

Fuel cell performance

Control and ancillaries

Electricity and heat transfer

Installation and operation

Commercial availability

Economics

Environment

Environmental aspects

Index of technical reviews

Voltage losses and voltage efficiency

The effective open circuit voltage is effected by the:
  • Cathode activation potential
  • Humidification of the fuel stream required to protect the anode from dehydration
  • Use of air instead of oxygen
As current is increased the voltage is reduced due to:
  • Internal resistance (proportional to the current and dependent on the temperature)
  • Local over-potentials at the electrodes (dependent on the current and temperature)
  • Concentration and mass transfer effects
These losses are dependent upon the detailed construction of the fuel cell including the internal connections to the electrodes. The resistance losses predominate except at very low or very high currents.

The concentration and mass transfer effects are described below.

Fuel utilisation and current efficiency

Excess air over that required for the reaction is always supplied for cooling purposes. Henceforth only fuel flows are considered.

The current is directly proportional to the fuel used as 1 mol of hydrogen yield 2 mols of electrons. However, the electrochemical reaction depends on the equilibrium constant which is dependent on the temperature and partial pressures, or concentrations of the reactants and products.


These parameters are non-uniform and vary throughout the fuel cell due to the 3D fluid flows along the flow passages and through the porous electrodes, concentration changes as reactants are used and products generated, and temperature changes from the heat of reaction and local cooling effects.

Modelling these effects in a fuel cell, such as that shown right, is very complex, and we use empirical methods in our assessment models.


Typical solid elctrolyte type fuel cell
Courtesy Ceramic Fuel Cells Ltd

The concentration effects include those on voltage, and the percentage of fuel which undergoes reaction. Thus some of the fuel will not be utilised and the actual current output will be less than the theoretical output calculated from the fuel input. This is expressed as the fuel utilisation or "current efficiency". Alternatively, the loss may be expressed as the "utilisation resistance".

Current-voltage characteristic

The typical fuel cell characteristic is shown below. This form of characteristic is presented in many research papers as a result of complex mathematical modelling or experiment.

Fuel cell characteristic

At near zero currents the conditions approach the constant theoretical conditions. Pressure losses, concentration changes, and temperature variations are infitesimal as the fuel passages are large compared with the fuel flows, and the reaction is infitesimal. Hence the voltage efficiency remains high at low currents. However, for a finite fuel flow rate the fuel utilisation or current efficiency will be very low.

As current increases, the voltage reduces due to the internal resistance, over-potentials, and concentration effects. Provided that excess fuel is supplied, the voltage decreases approximately linearly with current. When the fuel flow rate is limited the fuel utilisation or current efficiency increases with current but the linear relationship still applies up to approximately 80% utilisation.

If the fuel flow is regulated proportional to the current, current efficiency will be constant. Hence the voltage efficiency and overall efficiency is higher at low loads.

Performance at high currents and fuel utilisations

The quantity of fuel which can be distributed over the area of the cell is limited by mass transfer through the fuel passages. Theoretically the fuel utilisation cannot be greater than unity, and hence the maximum current that can be drawn from the fuel cell is limited.

The decrease in partial pressure of hydrogen due to increasing current and utilisation of the fuel can be substituted in the Nernst equation. Assuming perfect distribution of fuel or uniform partial pressure over the cell area, the voltage loss is negligible until all the fuel is used due to the high equilibrium constant. When the utilisation approaches 1 a sudden drop in voltage occurrs as ln p approaches -infinity.

However, in practice, at high fuel flows, the partial pressure and concentration of fuel will not reduce to zero simultaneously at all locations in the cell and the transition is smoother. This is shown by the actual voltage-current characteristic which becomes non-linear at fuel utilisations U>80%, and where V>0 when U=1.

Maximum power point

The voltage and overall efficiency of a fuel cell drops away at high currents due to the mass transfer effects described above. The maximum power point usually occurs on this part of the voltage-current characteristic and fuel cells are normally operated at less than maximum power point in the interests of efficiency. A rated operating point is normally chosen on the linear part of the characteristic.

Voltage regulation and fuel flow control

The following notes are based on our thinking, in the absence of any available information on fuel cell control.

The rated full load operating voltage of the fuel cell is chosen as described above, but at lower loads the output voltage of the fuel cell exceeds this. A constant voltage AC supply will normally be required, and for simplicity of the power conditioner, the excess voltage at partial loads may be dumped through a resistance.

Dropping the voltage at low loads by starving the fuel cell of fuel, and hence increasing the fuel utilisation efficiency at low loads has been considered but may be subject to problems:

  • The utilisation resistance is normally significantly lower than the internal/over-potential resistance up to the rated current. Hence the utilisation may need to approach unity to achieve the required voltage drop at low loads;
  • At near zero currents and fuel flows, mass transfer effects will not smooth out the the transition from low voltage loss to high voltage loss, and stability problems might result.
In any case, the potential fuel recovery from increased utilisation is low at low loads.

Due to the relatively flat voltage-current characteristic, and to avoid the above stability problems fuel flow control proportional to load current is recommended.

Characterising the performance in the Fuel Cell Mathematical Model

Voltage-current characteristics are obtained for the type of fuel cell, operating temperature and pressure, and fuel utilisations. In our spreadsheets characteristics are taken from research reports of development fuel cells. Characteristics of commercially available fuel cells should be used when published.

Since fuel flow is controlled proportional to current, the fuel utilisation or current efficiency will remain constant with current. A fuel utilisation with a reasonable voltage efficiency-current characteristic is selected (For maximum overall efficiency the voltage and current efficiency should be nearly equal but a lesser voltage efficiency will give a compromise between power and efficiency).

A maximum design current is selected on the substantially linear part of the voltage-current characteristic. The crossing point determines the operating voltage. Since excess voltage is dropped at partial loads to maintain a constant AC voltage, the effective DC voltage and voltage efficiency are constant with current (up to the maximum design current).

References

  1. S Zumdahl; Chemistry; Houghton Mifflin 1997
  2. P Costamagna & K Honegger; Modeling of Solid Oxide Heat Exchanger Integrated Stacks and Simulation at High Fuel Utilization; Journal of the Electrochemical Society, Vol 145, No 11, 1998
  3. F Standaerdt, K Hemmes, N Woudstra; Analyticl fuel cell modeling; Journal of Power Sources 63, 1996
  4. T Swaddle; Inorganic Chemistry; Academic Press 1997
  5. J Lee & T Lalk; Modeling fuel cell stack systems; Journal of Power Sources 73, 1998
  6. F Gardner; Thermodynamic processes in solid oxide and other fuel cells; Journal of power and energy, Part A, Proceedings, Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Vol 211, 1997



Return to top of page